Pakistan Opposition senators, including the leader of the opposition party, expressed severe criticism and reservations over the new budget for the upcoming fiscal year in the Upper House. They labeled it lethal for the public and suggested that taxes should be imposed on breathing, death, marriage, and childbirth.
Pakistan Budget Debate Sparks Controversy
During the budget debate, senators were vehement in their opposition. Some senators argued that those earning Rs. 50,000 or more are condemned to poverty. Opposition leader Shibli Faraz remarked that the budget’s objectives are unrealistic. Senator Emal Wali Khan warned that life will become difficult due to the burden of taxes. Taj Haider rejected any compromise, asserting his stance against it.
Criticism and Responses
Dinesh Kumar criticized the federal government for diverting funds from provinces to federal interests. Maulana Abdul Wasey recounted an incident involving a Hindu senator claiming to have received a divine order, which led to a public uproar. Shibli Faraz criticized the budget as lethal for the public, emphasizing that imposing taxes on certain sectors could further deteriorate the economy. He accused the People’s Party of transforming into a party focused on self-interest rather than ideology.
Pakistan Government’s Defense and Opposition’s Role
Government representative Irfan Siddiqui defended the budget during the debate, urging constructive criticism and positive recommendations for national development. He called on the opposition to contribute to the country’s progress rather than engage in mere point-scoring. The Deputy Speaker highlighted the ministers’ absence during the session, demanding their consistent presence with relevant ministry officials in the Senate.
Summary
Senator Mian Mohammad Aslam Khan summarized the sentiment, stating that the budget has distressed the nation. The heated debate underscores the deep divisions and contentious issues surrounding fiscal policies and governance in Pakistan.
