We will decide on the petitions contesting the relocation of election tribunals and the appointment of retired judges to these bodies within a couple of days from today.
Conclusion for Arguments
At this stage in the proceedings, Chief Justice Farooq requests that any additional judicial precedents be submitted quickly. “In case you have any judicial precedents, bring them forward. We are waiting for the order, and I will try to announce the decision as soon as possible, hopefully within a day or two,” said Chief Justice Farooq.
PTI’s Lawyer’s Position
While arguing against PTI candidates’ petitions, Farrell Chadwick Mughal’s lawyer presented his rebuttal. The language used in this petition is inappropriate because it emphasizes what was not done to protect its integrity”,” he underscored. According to Chaudhry, the Election Commission cannot dismiss a tribunal under electoral law.
Legal Positions
Chief Justice Farooq then enquired whether, once formed, a tribunal could be stopped from winding up its business. Faisal Chaudhry confirmed that a tribunal could be transferred but could not be terminated. Another assister lawyer added that no administrative body could transfer a Judge of the High Court. Therefore, government counsel pointed out that there was no court order prohibiting termination of the tribunal.
Observations Made by Court on Tribunal’s Conduct
“I am not suggesting that what happened at the court (tribunal) was correct,” observed Chief Justice Farooq. Many things were said during proceedings here and in the Election Commission that do not affect the decision made.” If any other submissions are still pending, kindly submit them now before I deliver my judgment within one or two days.”
Ending
Chief Justice Aamer Faoroque informed yesterday that within a few days, his verdict would end deliberation on the challenges, challenging the transfer of election tribunals and appointment of retired judges. After outlining the critical issue, Chief Justice Amir Farooq hinted that a decision was near. This will significantly impact the running of election tribunals and current litigation regarding election disputes.
